Homepage of the Marie Curie Excellence Grant MEXT-CT-2006-042471


Search, Switching Costs and the Design of Optimal Competition Policy


Summary of the Project:

 

In real-world markets consumers face search and switching costs. These costs have received significant theoretical consideration in separate literatures. The received wisdom is that search and switching costs have pervasive consequences in markets because they confer market power to the firms. As a result, prices are often dispersed and higher than what is desirable from a welfare standpoint.

 

Despite a significant theoretical effort, search and switching costs are to a large extent ignored when it comes to competition policy and antitrust economics. There are at least three reasons for this omission. One, existing work has largely focused on specific market structures, namely markets with infinitely many firms (search cost literature) or duopolistic (switching cost literature) and therefore has failed to examine oligopolistic market structures (markets with a finite and arbitrary number of firms), far more reaching in real-world markets and central to antitrust economics. Two, the work on identification and quantification of search and switching costs is practically inexistent (see relevant literature below). Three, in many markets search and switching costs operate at a time and there is no prior work considering both search and switching costs together.

 

This project aims at developing a series of demand and supply (market) models of the interaction of firms and consumers and corresponding econometrics methods to estimate search and switching costs. As such, the results of the project should be of interest to regulatory and antitrust authorities.


Budget: 1.200.000 Euro, funded by a Marie Curie Excellence Grant (for Marie Curie actions, see here)


Duration of the project: September 1, 2007 to August 31, 2011.


People:

 

Team Leader: Prof. Dr. Jose Luis Moraga

Post-doc: Dr. Zsolt Sandor

Post-doc: Dr. Marielle Non (from 01/08/08 to 31/08/10)

Post-doc: Dr. Franco Mariuzzo (from 01/09/07 to 30/10/08)

Post-doc: Dr. Federico Crudu (from 16/08/09 to 16/08/11)

Ph. D. student: Vaiva Petrikaite


Output, work in progress and related publications:

 

Ph.D. Thesis

 

The Effects of Costly Consumer Search on Mergers and Cartels (Vaiva Petrikaite)

Theoretical papers:

Platform Intermediation in a Market for Differentiated Products (joint with Andrea Galeotti) European Economic Review, 53, 417-428, 2009.

Competing for Attention in a Consumer Search Model (Marco Haan and J.L. Moraga-Gonzalez), The Economic Journal, 121, 552-579, 2011.

Consumer Search Costs and the Incentives to Merge under Bertrand Competition (J.L. Moraga-Gonzalez and V. Petrikaite)

Tinbergen Institute Discussion Paper # TI 2011-099/1, The Netherlands, June 2010. (Revise and resubmit to the RAND Journal of Economics)

 

Comparison Sites (with M. Wildenbeest), Handbook of the Digital Economy, forthcoming.

 

Horizontal Mergers and Economies of Search (J.L. Moraga-Gonzalez and V. Petrikaite)

 

On Mergers in Consumer Search Markets (M. Janssen and J.L. Moraga-Gonzalez) Tinbergen Institute Discussion Paper # 07-054/1, The Netherlands, June 2007

 

Non-sequential Search Equilibrium with Search Cost Heterogeneity IESE Business School Working Paper WP-869, July 2010.

 

Isolation or Joining a Mall? On the Location Choice of Competing Shops (Marielle Non), MPRA WP # 20044, January 2010.

 

A Model of Switching Costs with Boundedly Rational Consumers (Marielle Non).

 

Heterogeneous Price Information and the Effect of Competition (S. Lach and J.L. Moraga-Gonzalez)

 

Empirical papers:

 

Coverage of retail stores and discrete choice models of demand: Estimating price elasticities and welfare effects (F. Mariuzzo, P.P. Walsh and C. Whelan), International Journal of Industrial Organization 28 (2010) 555-578.

 

Maximum Likelihood Estimation of Search Costs (J.L. Moraga-Gonzalez and M. Wildenbeest), European Economic Review,

52, 820-848, 2008.

 

Estimating the Price Overcharge from Cartelisation of the Irish Automobile Industry (F. Mariuzzo, P.P. Walsh and O. van Parys.) The Economic and Social Review, 40(2):165–182, 2009. (paper)

 

Semi-Nonparametric Estimation of Consumer Search Costs (J.L. Moraga-Gonzalez, Z. Sandor and M. Wildenbeest) revised and resubmitted to the Journal of Applied Econometrics.

 

On the Identification of the Costs of Simultaneous Search (J.L. Moraga-Gonzalez, Zsolt Sandor and Matthijs Wildenbeest), Tinbergen Institute Discussion Paper # 2010-066/1, The Netherlands, 2010.

 

Consumer Search and Prices in the Automobile Market (J.L. Moraga-Gonzalez, Z. Sandor and M. Wildenbeest), 2011.

 

Conditional EL for dependent data (F. Crudu and Z. Sandor)

 

MC Simulation of Discrete Choice Models Involving Large Sums (Z. Sandor).

 

Asymmetric Price Effects of Competition (S. Lach and J.L. Moraga-Gonzalez) CEPR Discussion Paper 7319, June 2009.

 

Semi-parametric Maximum Likelihood Estimation of Market Equilibrium Models (Z. Sandor)

 

Other related papers:

 

Strategic Pricing, Consumer Search and the Number of Firms (M. Janssen and J.L. Moraga-Gonzalez), Review of Economic Studies, 71, 1089-1118, 2004.

 

Truly Costly Sequential Search and Oligopolistic Pricing (M. Janssen, M. Wildenbeest and J.L. Moraga-Gonzalez), International Journal of Industrial Organization 23, 451-466, 2005.

 

Structural Estimation of Search Intensity: Do Non-employed Workers Search Enough? (P. Gautier, J.L. Moraga-Gonzalez and R. Wolthoff), Tinbergen Institute Discussion Paper # 2007-071/3, The Netherlands, 2007.

 

 

 

Workshops

1st Workshop Search and Switching Costs

Thursday 17 and Friday 18 December 2009

University of Groningen

Venue: Het Kasteel, Melkweg 1, Groningen

 

*********************

 

2nd Workshop Search and Switching Costs

Monday 23 and Tuesday 24 May 2011

University of Groningen

Venue: Het Kasteel, Melkweg 1, Groningen